Case File 121: Halloween H20

It’s the season finale of Rogues Gallery, and our final investigation of the year leads us into the eerily empty halls of Hillcrest Academy for a look back at Halloween H20: 20 Years Later.

What began as a modest direct-to-video sequel was reborn as a prestige anniversary event, bringing Jamie Lee Curtis back for one last confrontation with the Shape... or so we thought.

We dig into how a late-stage rewrite and a scrapped subplot shaped this sleek, surprisingly brisk entry, and whether the glossy, post-Scream style enhances or undermines what made the early films so haunting. Along the way, we also unpack the chaotic saga of the four different Michael Myers masks, the eleventh-hour overhaul of its controversial score, and whether or not it truly delivers the cathartic ending it intended.

Finally, we debate where H20 ranks among the Halloween films we’ve covered thus far, and Kristen makes her predictions for the next entry.

Our next season begins in February 2026.

The Show
Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Facebook | Instagram

The Hosts
Chris's Instagram | Kristen's Instagram

Chris & Kristen's Web Series:
The Strange Case of Lucy Chandler